Made from Scratch
Custom Cakes & Baked Goods

Fresh Made Cakes, Cupcakes, Cookies and a Whole Lot More!
Our Selection
Land of books youtube cooking gaaf66359e 1920


Welcome To
Our Bakery

Tasty Sweets N' Treats is a bakery located on the North Shore of Long Island in Port Jefferson, NY. We pride ourselves in our high quality, made from scratch assortments for any occasion. You’ll enjoy our fresh, delicious cupcakes, cookies, pies, and other pastries. You'll also enjoy our various homemade candies. If you have a wedding, birthday, or other special occasion coming up, our friendly staff can help supply you and your guests with the right assortments of cupcakes, cookies, pies, and many more delicious desserts or special requests. We are confident our desserts and/or other baked goods will wow you and your guests. At the moment, we are Online Orders Only, however, we have fast and reliable shipping methods and often can ship items to you within the same week you place your order. Want to enjoy the excellence of a local Long Island Bakery beyond the our beautiful island? Of course you do! And we can help with that! We can ship items in a temperature controlled packaging and packed with dry ice to ensure your baking products stay fresh while in transit. If you have a catering event off Long Island that you would like us to personally deliver our baking products to, we can arrange that with you through our catering services. We are capable of bringing our baking services and products to you in all 50 U.S. States!
Read More

Menu Favorites
Our Selection


 
Mike meeks zk fcljdgas unsplash

Cupcakes

Our cupcakes are treated like “mini cakes” in that they get the same level of attention and quality as what you would expect from a specialty cake. We’ll even arrange them elegantly on a cupcake tree.
Click Here
Tball cookies gaf23e86dc 1920

Cookies

At Tasty Sweets N' Treats, we bake many different kinds of cookies from scratch every day. We can even create custom decorated cookies for any occasion.
Click Here
Eclair g21efcb6dd 1920

Pastries & More

We enjoy making other pastries from scratch such as brownies, pies, cinnamon rolls, and muffins. We can also accommodate most special requests such as vegan or sugar-free.
Click Here

Dog Treats

At Tasty Sweets N' Treats, we recognize your pups as family and bake our very own dog treats that are made with all natural ingredients and make for a healthy treat. But don't worry, your pup won't know they are a healthy treat and will love them just as much as you love the rest of our delicious desserts. All our dog treats are doggy taste tested by our very own Dakota the Husky!
Click Here
Pexels doughnuts g9d858187c 1920

Quality You Can Taste
What Sets Us Apart

We know that there are plenty of other bakeries on Long Island for you to choose from. However, you’ll find that we’re different from most other places. We are a family-owned business that uses time-honored recipes passed from one generation to the next. We pride ourselves on using the highest quality products in all of our baked goods to create delicious, one of a kind creations.

Highest Quality Ingredients
We do not take shortcuts with quality. We only source our ingredients from top notch suppliers.

One Of A Kind Creations
We have crafted all sorts of unique special requested orders. If you can dream it, we can create it!

Always Fresh & Always Delicious
All of our baked goods and candies are freshly made from scratch each day. You’ll love our sweet treats!
Contact Us

Custom Orders are Our Specialty!

Planning a party or event? We make custom orders for any occasion.
Contact us to place an order.

Wedding Desserts • Bridal Shower Cakes • Baby Shower Cakes • Gender Reveal Cakes • Birthday Cakes & Desserts • Sweet 16 Desserts • Anniversary Desserts • Themed Desserts • Retirement Cakes & Desserts
Contact Us

Custom Cakes & More
Check Out Some of Our Creations
 

Luisana zerpa mjpr6nodppw unsplash
Phinehas adams wp4zymuujbk unsplash
Bryam blanco nxkwln8y9qe unsplash
Mike meeks zk fcljdgas unsplash
Smdesigns ai generated g5ed81d43d 1920
Image

Martinl21 red velvet cake g55fde9c88 1920

Tball cookies gaf23e86dc 1920

Pexels doughnuts g9d858187c 1920

Rollingpin transition

Satisfied Customers
Read Our Reviews
 

Girl g6f3b89546 1920 960x960 circle
“The chocolate chip brownies were excellent at my daughter's birthday party. It was very quiet at dessert because all the kids were too busy enjoying all the treats we ordered. I will gladly order again from Tasty Sweets N' Treats!”
— Katie B.
Man g7d2999b7d 1920 960x960 circle
“Thank you for making our anniversary extra special. I was a new customer who needed a Happy Anniversary cake fast, and these guys delivered a high quality cake in a timely manner.”
— Brandon F.
Josue michel x8y0mjcvs6g unsplash 960x960 circle
“My daughter and her BFF recently had their Sweet 16 birthday celebration. The custom made chocolate cake we ordered from Tasty Sweets N' Treats was beautiful and delicious. The price and everything else was just right.”
— Laura C.